I have a question for you....
"Can you can a can as a canner can can a can?"
It's a very simple question... you either can or you can't!
This is a real sentence, with correct grammar, spelling and everything.
But for English students, this question may not be so simple, either to understand or say.
As for English teachers, this can be a 10-30 minute lesson in grammar, pronunciation and just being silly!
First, let's look at the meaning...
Can you Here, "Can" is a modal verb, asking the question 'do you have the ability?' Can you do something?
Can a Can
Here, we ask 'what is a can?' Like a can of soup, a can of beer, canned fish...it's a metal container, usually to keep food. That's a can.
What does it mean to 'can a can?' Well, in factories, people make cans, or maybe they use a machine to put things inside a can. This is the meaning of can a can, an action verb meaning to put something in a can!
As a Canner Just like a person who teaches is a teach-er and someone who works is a work-er, somebody who cans is a .....canner! AS a canner means LIKE a canner, or in a similar way to a canner.
Can Modal verb of ability
Can Action verb, to make a can
a Can? A metal container for food or liquid
So, I'll ask the question again...
"Can you can a can as a canner can can a can?"
or in other words....
Do you have the ability to put something in a can like a person whose job it is to put things in cans has the ability to put things in cans?
I agree, the first one is much easier to say..;)
Try to say it...
Try to say it 2 times.....
Now try 3 times!.....
Say it 3 times FAST!!!
canyoucanacanasacannercancanacan?...canyoucanacanasacannercancanacan?...canyoucanacanasacannercancanacan?
Nice.:)
If you have a friend to try this with, you can take turns asking the question and answering it...
For example:
Q: Can you can a can as a canner can can a can?
A: Yes, I can can a can as a canner can can a can.
or
A: No, I can't can a can as a canner can can a can.
Teachers: For more information on methods of turning tongue twisters into ESOL lessons, stay tuned to this blog and look out for an upcoming e-book from the blogger.:)